The bold journey of the 2018 Freedom Flotilla Coalition dared Palestinians and the world to dream of peace, dignity and freedom for all. Now, we must keep working to build a culture of nonviolence, writes Elizabeth Murray.
By Elizabeth Murray
Special to Consortium News
What’s next for the 2018 Freedom Flotilla Coalition?
In August, the crew and passengers of the Freedom Flotilla ships, Al Awda and Freedom, returned to their home countries after being hijacked, interrogated and imprisoned by Israeli commandos. The outcome may have appeared anticlimactic, since many supporters had hoped for a triumphant arrival by the flotilla ships in Gaza Harbor and a breaking of Israel’s illegal 12-year land and sea blockade of the small Palestinian enclave.
But in many ways, the 2018 Freedom Flotilla mission has achieved its goals—which were to challenge the Israeli blockade of Gaza, raise public awareness of the blockade and other human rights violations, and let the people of Gaza know that they are not alone.
Of course, had the flotilla ships been able to reach Gaza unhindered, it would have been a remarkable accomplishment and the first time the blockade had been breached in 10 years.
Back then—in August 2008—two boats carrying international solidarity activists sailed into Gaza’s shores to a hero’s welcome from the locals, including children, who swam out to greet them. It was a dramatic display of people-to-people solidarity against the illegal Israeli blockade.
Their arrival in Gaza was momentous and cathartic, and served notice to the people of Gaza that their plight—and Israel’s criminal blockade—had not gone unnoticed by the world. Israel has since shown great resolve in its determination to prevent such a display of humanity and solidarity from ever recurring again—even at the cost of innocent lives.
Since then, Israel has blocked similar solidarity ships from arriving in Gaza, either by hijacking them in international waters (as took place this year) or by pressuring other governments to detain the ships, as when the Greek government compelled the Gaza-bound Audacity of Hope to return to port shortly after its departure from Athens—under threat of armed force.
A Challenge to Israel
In 2010, heavily armed Israeli commandos boarded the Gaza-bound cruise ship Mavi Marmara, assaulting and injuring numerous passengers and killing nine of them, including a U.S. citizen. Despite the clear death threat from Israel, the Freedom Flotilla boats keep coming, including the Estelle in 2012 and the Marianne in 2015, challenging the Israeli blockade.
The Freedom Flotilla phenomenon makes it evident that the movement’s momentum, persistence and staying power have little to do with its actual physical arrival in Gaza and more to do with other less tangible aspects of the journey.
The actual act of challenging Israel’s illegal land and sea blockade of the Gaza Strip is in itself a bold and even revolutionary statement of the need to hold Israel accountable under international law for its human rights violations. These repeated sea-based challenges to Israeli impunity have garnered international attention and admiration from the grassroots public—particularly in view of the unwillingness of governments to acknowledge and confront Israel’s 70-year subjugation and occupation of the Palestinian people.
The Freedom Flotilla’s international composition—with crew and delegates of numerous nationalities (including New Zealand, Malaysia, Australia, Canada, First Nations, Spain, Israel, United States, Norway, Sweden, etc.) has inspired and energized Palestinians in the diaspora and in their homeland. They realize that this small group of activists willing to undergo significant collective risk to highlight the Palestinians’ plight and break the silence represents the world’s people.
Palestinians have responded by staging bold nonviolent actions of their own, such as the recent series of seaborne flotillas Gaza fishermen initiated to challenge the sea blockade and protest Israel’s arbitrary fishing restrictions and random acts of terrorism against fishers, who are routinely harassed and shot at while they are trying to fish, and whose fishing boats are either shot up or confiscated. Diaspora Palestinians showed up in large numbers to greet, celebrate and host the Freedom Flotilla at every port of call.
United Against Inhumanity
The Freedom Flotilla’s engagement of local grassroots community organizations, media interviews, interaction with the public through boat tours and one-on-one conversations have raised the profile of Gaza’s plight, reminding the outside world that residents of Gaza have no freedom of movement, and that repeated, massive Israeli aerial bombings have disabled the electricity grid, destroyed the sewage treatment plant and rendered 98 percent of the water undrinkable.
Meanwhile, the blockade prevents the entry of critical food, medicine and construction materials—preventing Gazans from rebuilding or repairing their destroyed homes and infrastructure.
Freedom Flotilla delegates were honored at parliamentary sessions and feted by local dignitaries and government officials in several cities along their route, raising the profile of Palestinian suffering under the Israeli blockade. As a result, the Freedom Flotilla earned explicit statements of political support for their anti-blockade mission from the Spanish municipality of Asturias-Gijon and from other grassroots political organizations.
Some Freedom Flotilla participants have provided media accounts describing abusive treatment at the hands of their Israeli captors, including this piece by United Kingdom-based Al Awda delegate and orthopedic surgeon Dr. Swee Ang. This reporting has outraged the public in their respective countries and redoubled the resolve of many organizations to promote the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement (BDS).
Roger Waters, the musician of Pink Floyd fame and an active proponent of BDS, recently invited several Freedom Flotilla crew members to his August concert in Oslo and publically hailed them as his “heroes.”
Indeed, in the wake of the Freedom Flotilla action, the BDS movement has seen several notable successes. At least 15 international bands and artists have withdrawn from an Israeli music festival. Six of 11 invited speakers also have confirmed their withdrawal from a scientific forum at Ariel University, which is built on occupied Palestinian land in an Israeli settlement. Palestinian scholars had urged speakers to withdraw, citing Israeli travel restrictions on Palestinian academics. As Israeli crimes against Palestinians continue unchecked, these developments build on the international outrage.
At the same time, the Freedom Flotilla’s nonviolent challenge to Israel’s blockade coincided with the (still ongoing) weekly protest by Gazans known as the Great March of Return. During this peaceful action—in which unarmed Palestinians have been asserting their rights to liberty and freedom—Israeli snipers have been shooting and killing civilians of all ages, including children, women and medical workers. Casualties now are in the thousands. Images of the victims of Israeli violence have elicited expressions of disgust and outrage toward Israel, as well as sympathy and support for Palestinian freedom.
Giving Palestinians a Voice
These are the atrocities that have moved members of the Freedom Flotilla to risk their own lives to make a change.
First Mate Charlie Andreasson, a red-haired, blue-eyed Swede,explains: “Anything I’ve suffered at the hands of the Israelis is nothing compared to what the Palestinians suffer.”
Asked why he was on his third Freedom Flotilla mission (he was aboard the Estelle and Marianne), Andreasson said: “I have blue eyes and white skin. I may as well put them to good use.” The remark alluded to an awareness that because of his race and nationality, any suffering he might be subjected to would draw international media attention—unlike the suffering of ordinary Gazans, whose daily tragedies and humiliations pass largely unnoticed by most Western news services.
Andreasson noted that historically, change is not initiated by governments, but by ordinary people “who have had enough” and who are “standing united against injustice.” He cited as examples the U.S. civil rights movement, women’s rights, the fall of the apartheid regime in South Africa, and the rights of LGBT persons.
“So I believe we are wasting our energy when time after time we demand that our governments take action instead of getting people united around the world,” he said. “That is why we have to get our asses off the sofa and start to make a change. After all, we want to be able to look at ourselves in the mirror without feeling ashamed that we didn’t do anything.”
Addressing those who might not be up for a sea journey to Gaza, Andreasson counseled: “You don’t have to sail with the Freedom Flotilla, you don’t have to risk your life or take any time off—it can be enough just to refuse to buy Israeli products.”
Divina Levrini, a passenger aboard the Al Awda who also hails from Sweden and, like Andreasson, is a veteran of previous Freedom Flotilla journeys, said she has worked on behalf of the Palestinian cause since her teenage years. It was “a natural thing” for her “to go and try to put an end to the blockade” since she has been educating others about it for so many years. “If it takes Westerners to give the Palestinians a voice, so be it,” she said.
Levrini thought the flotilla “made a difference.” In addition to the “very important” media publicity, the flotilla mission helped bring about political change, she said. “During the two-and-one-half months the flotilla journeyed from port to port, we actually compelled politicians to act,” she said—a reference in part to Navarre becoming the first Spanish state to adopt a BDS resolution.
Pointing to the dire United Nations warning that Gaza would be “uninhabitable” in two years, Levrini stated that political change “is what Gaza needs. They need that change right now. We need to take an extreme course of action to make a change.”
Asked what message she would like to send to Israel, Levrini—who briefly staged a hunger strike during her incarceration in Israel to protest prison conditions—stated: “My only message to Israel is a bold one. The ships will continue to sail until Palestine is free from Israeli terror.”
Right to a Just Future
Before we can move toward any real justice in Gaza, more people need to acknowledge the injustice that exists.
On July 29, Israeli Navy gunboats surrounded the Al Awda as it approached Gaza Harbor with 22 passengers and crew aboard (five days later, the Freedom followed with 12 aboard). Masked commandos armed with machine guns boarded the ship and violently tasered and assaulted several passengers and crew members, including the ship’s captain, Norwegian national Herman Reksten. They did this despite being repeatedly advised by Al Awda crew member Mikkel Gruener by radio that the Al Awda was in international waters and “wanted no business” with Israel.
The Israelis seemed to reserve a special contempt for the mostly Norwegian crew. Not only did they physically assault them, but they tore down the Norwegian flag and trampled it underfoot, deeply offending the crew members, who managed to salvage it.
Both the Al Awda and the boats were purchased, refurbished, and outfitted through the private donations of Freedom Flotilla supporters from around the world. They were to have been delivered to Gaza’s fishers as gifts of friendship and solidarity from the international seafarers. Instead, Israel has confiscated them and looted the personal effects of the passenger and crew on both flotilla ships—taking laptops computers, camera equipment, watches, credit cards, cell phones, clothing and cash.
“They stole everything,” said Levrini, who was reduced to tears after witnessing Israeli commandos savagely beat, head-slam and then threaten to execute Al Awda captain Reksten. First Mate Andreasson tweeted that Israel “stole our private belongings” adding: “Once again, we got to know what it’s like to be Palestinians.”
Perhaps worst of all has been the Israeli military’s failure thus far to release 114 boxes of medical supplies—including medical gauze and sutures for the Gaza health system—that had been loaded onto the Al Awda just prior to the final leg of its journey. The consignment of medical aid was to have provided needed medical supplies and equipment to a populace being bombed and shot at mercilessly, even as weekly Great March of Return demonstrations at the no-man’s land between Gaza and Israel continue. A petition is circulating to demand that the medical supplies be delivered to Gaza.
The passengers and crew of the Freedom Flotilla boats are people of privilege. We can travel freely and do not have to deal with incessant Israeli repression, violence and humiliation. We know our experience cannot hold a candle to what people living in Gaza are forced to endure under Israel’s suffocating yoke of oppression.
But the bold journey of the Freedom Flotilla Coalition dared Palestinians and the world to dream—to dream of a day when people of the world unite with such fervor for justice and human rights that barriers and obstacles will fall away, and peace, dignity, and freedom will be possible for all.
The sentiment of all those who shared in the Freedom Flotilla’s journey—passengers, crew, and the land-based support teams—perhaps can best be summed up by the words of Irish Nobel Peace Prize recipient Mairead Maguire, a veteran of many Gaza solidarity boat journeys (one of the 2018 Freedom Flotilla ships was named after her) who understands the challenge ahead.
“I believe, with Gandhi, that we need to take an imaginative leap toward fresh and generous idealism for the sake of humanity—that we need to renew this ancient wisdom of nonviolence, to strive for a disarmed world, and to create a culture of nonviolence.”
Elizabeth Murray served as Deputy National Intelligence Officer for the Near East in the National Intelligence Council before retiring after a 27-year career in the U.S. government, where she specialized in Middle Eastern political and media analysis. She is a member of Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS). Murray was a delegate on the first leg of this year’s Freedom Flotilla.
If you valued this original article, please consider making a donation to Consortium News so we can bring you more stories like this one.
Thank you Ms. Murray for a fine article and your activism. I was the engineer on the Al Awda from Oslo to Kiel Germany and am a good friend and shipmate of Charlie. I don’t remember meeting you but I must have been with you during that first leg of the flotilla. Perhaps you were on one of the other ships. Hopefully we will meet again on another flotilla or in Gaza. Bye for now. Kevin Neish, Victoria, B.C., Canada.
What exactly is “freedom” for Palestine?
Palestine is free. It’s Gaza that is occupied, by an illegal terrorist group.
“Palestine” is the historic name of the Jewish nation, dating back as far as recorded history. Through its long history, it was often under the control of various foreign powers. While so many were driven into exile, the region always included a Jewish population. The Jewish nation was restored following the Holocaust, in 1948, and renamed Israel. It’s worth stressing that Israel, although portrayed as a military aggressor, is roughly 1% of the Mideast. A portion of our population evidently thinks that a “fair partitioning” of the Mideast would be:100% for the Arabs, 0% for the Jews. Not that this has anything to do with Jews, mind you…
No comfort or rest for the criminal regime in Tel Aviv.
Before the next flotilla sets sail, I would like to see a country to step-up, provide escort and put Israel leaders on notice, that the world will not accept their behavior in this matter anymore.
What about it New Zealand, Australia, Canada, Sweden ?
I’m not holding my breath.
Much in the way, I’m sick of the US bullying the world, I’m sick of Israel bullying the ME.
Ha! Not bloody likely. Integrity and courage are in short supply in Ottawa these days.
There’s almost total lockdown on truth in the US and what’s told is Orwellian bass-ackward. Yeah, F. G., I am totally sick of hearing “Iran is the largest state sponsor of terrorism” (Pompous Pompeo), when it’s the US, its misleaders are completely in service to Israel and Netanyahu (i like somebody’s name Satanyahoo). Without major exposure of the Israel lobby’s chokehold on US politics including complicit media, how to wake up the slumberers? No one should be allowed to draw a government paycheck who holds dual citizenship of US and Israel, as i believe Bolton does and lots more including Wolfowitz, who led the charge into Iraq with Cheney. Israel is the third rail of US politics and has been for far too long.
Awakening the American conscience is a massive undertaking which is probably impossible. Without this awakening, we are screwed on every front plain and simple.
Any person with a reasonable degree of awareness and conscience can see what needs to be done in our world. We simply lack having anywhere near enough people with that rudimentary level of consciousness. Sleeping people will not build a world based on intelligence, compassion, and awareness. I wish there was a simple easy way to cultivate those qualities in the short time left to us, but I am not aware of anything that will do that. Adios amigos….
JOHN CHUCKMAN : The US has more than helped. If you study the relationship, you can see that Israel is really an American colony in the Mideast. John, you have some great posts here and I have read some of your blogs/essays. Yet I am compelled to correct you on this one.
The US is an Israeli colony not the other way around. The evidence is ample. It is the classic example of the ‘tail wagging the dog’. The executive branch of government is owned and controlled (embassy in Jerusalem – following orders); judicial branch is 1/3 Zionist, 1/3 Zionist sympathetic, and 1/3 easily bent to the Zionist majority; the legislative branch is totally owned – see Mersheimer and Walt’s 2007 novel detailing how and why.
It should be mandatory that every US citizen read ‘The Israel Lobby’ by Mersheimer and Walt. In support of that, youtube Cynthia McKinney on the Lobby requiring all members of congress to sign a pledge in support of Israel – a foreign nation 1st above the country congress is elected to serve! Then google Oded Yinon’s 1982 strategy for greater israel. Now we can connect the dots.
How can the zionists fulfill their desire to own the land between the Nile and Euphrates? By controlling not just the USA’s law making branch, congress, but controlling the entire government, economy (the Fed) and finance, media, education, and deep state. The result is to use the USA’s blood and treasure to destabilize the entire region (7 countries in 5 years) to eliminate all resistance to greater israel, which is half way done. We are totally owned and controlled in every aspect to serve the zionist agenda.
It’s a lovely use of my tax dollars to serve a foreign country first while the infrastructure sits crumbling before our eyes; healthcare devolved into insurance, and my constitutionally protected rights are eviscerated to eliminate any criticism or accountability of the zionist project’s abrogation of law and human decency. Just wonderful isn’t it?
I look forward to making a donation, again, when these courageous bothers and sisters prepare their next journey to protest against the largest prison in the world. I feel both guilty (for not having the courage to participate) and proud (to see that such admirable people still exist). Thank you!
It is important to keep trying.
Every instance shows the Israeli government for what it is, a gang of pirates.
As a person who was formally misinformed on this topic I would just like to say my heart, Energy and when possible spear cash will go how to helping the Palestinian people for this horrendous injustice that the United States has helped to perpetrate.
The US has more than helped.
If you study the relationship, you can see that Israel is really an American colony in the Mideast.
It couldn’t even exist without immense subsidies, public and private.
Yes, and the “private” subsidies may be even larger than the “public” government subsidies which support this abominable anachronism masquerading as “the only democracy in the Middle East”. Is anyone out there in the civilian world familiar with the so-called “Combined Federal Campaign”? In order to mollify the disruption caused by “charitable” organizations attempting to shake down military members and government employees for donations, this program was developed. Every year, a large pamphlet is aggregated including hundreds of charitable organizations eligible to receive contributions. Each organization gets a little blurb describing its “official” charitable activities along with a coded identification. Members receive a copy of the pamphlet along with a form to make a donation. The form can be sent to the member’s disbursing office to make a one-time donation or a monthly allotment deducted from the member’s salary. God only knows how much this additional accounting burden adds to the U. S. Government’s overhead. Many years ago, I sat down with one of those pamphlets and a highlighter. As I recall, I counted thirteen agencies which directly or indirectly supported our “colonial project”. All of that “charity” goes to a country with a higher standard of living than our own citizens enjoy. If you add in the auxiliary agencies which provide propaganda support for the “project” — such as NPR — an already gargantuan fraud becomes even larger. Speaking of gargantuan, is anybody else tired of hearing that overused lie: “Iran is the largest state sponsor of terrorism”? I know they’re not choir boys, but if our government is in bed with Jabhat al Nusra in Syria — as Tulsi Gabbard points out — we ain’t got much room to point fingers.