Marjorie Cohn explains what the U.S. president can do to alleviate the suffering of the Cuban people.
The corporate media have been bashing the Cuban government in response to the recent protests in Cuba, while President Joe Biden claims, “We stand with the Cuban people.” But they ignore or minimize the leading cause of economic suffering in Cuba: the U.S. illegal and punishing economic blockade that Biden has left in place.
Every U.S. president since Dwight D. Eisenhower has maintained the blockade against Cuba. Although former President Barack Obama was constrained by the 1996 Helms-Burton Act from completely lifting the blockade — which is now exclusively within the power of Congress — he took several steps to ease its effects on the Cuban people.
In 2015, Obama loosened restrictions on Americans traveling to Cuba and ended some of the economic prohibitions between the U.S. and Cuba. He removed Cuba from the list of state sponsors of terrorism and facilitated the export of U.S internet hardware and telecommunications. Obama established increased cooperation between the two countries in intelligence-gathering, drug interdiction, scientific research and environmental protection.
But former President Donald Trump reversed the progress Obama had made and imposed 243 onerous new sanctions on Cuba as part of his “maximum pressure” strategy against Cuba. Those punishing sanctions, together with the pandemic, spelled disaster for the Cuban people. Trump also returned Cuba to the list of state sponsors of terrorism.
Please Support Our Summer Fund Drive!
Trump’s actions included restricting and then stopping remittances from family members outside Cuba. They blocked cruise ships and most flights to Cuba, even though tourism is central to Cuba’s economy. They reinstated a travel ban for U.S. tourists and prevented Cuba from buying medicines and medical supplies on the world market. Trump also slapped sanctions on the transportation of oil to Cuba from Venezuela, which provided one-third of Cuba’s oil in 2019.
During his presidential campaign, Biden repeatedly hitched his coattails to Obama’s star and promised to lift Trump’s sanctions against Cuba. But Biden has refused to end any of Trump’s sanctions on Cuba, even calling it a “failed state.” Ned Price, a U.S. State Department spokesman, dismissively called the embargo the “so-called embargo” and refused to admit that the ban on remittances was hurting the Cuban economy.
“If President Joe Biden really had humanitarian concerns for the Cuban people he would eliminate the 243 measures applied by President Donald Trump, including 50 imposed cruelly during the pandemic,” Cuban President Miguel Diaz-Canel wrote on his Twitter account.
Inflicting ‘Hunger, Desperation & Overthrow
“[C]urrent events in Cuba are a direct consequence of the interventionism of the US government, be it of the Democratic or Republican Party, and their plans to suffocate the country and cause disorder and chaos, to destroy the Cuban Revolution and its example,” the American Association of Jurists, a nongovernmental organization with consultative status at the United Nations, said in a recent statement.
Indeed, since the 1959 Cuban Revolution, the U.S. government has sustained a cruel economic, financial and commercial embargo against Cuba. By pressuring other countries not to trade with Cuba, it has become a blockade. The U.S. embargo of Cuba was launched by Eisenhower in response to a 1960 memo written by a senior State Department official, which set forth the U.S. strategy for regime change in Cuba. The memo said:
“The only foreseeable means of alienating internal support is through disenchantment and disaffection based on economic dissatisfaction and hardship … every possible means should be undertaken promptly to weaken the economic life of Cuba … a line of action which, while as adroit and inconspicuous as possible, makes the greatest inroads in denying money and supplies to Cuba, to decrease monetary and real wages, to bring about hunger, desperation and overthrow of government.”
For the last six decades, the blockade has caused the Cuban people immense suffering. But it has not succeeded in destroying the Cuban Revolution.
In 1997, the American Association for World Health concluded that the blockade had “dramatically harmed the health and nutrition of large numbers of ordinary Cuban citizens” and “caused a significant rise in suffering — and even deaths — in Cuba” as a result of “critical shortages of even the most basic medicines and medical hardware.”
Over the past six decades, the blockade has caused more than $134 billion in quantifiable losses as of 2018.
The blockade violates the UN Charter, which enshrines the right to self-determination of sovereign states and prohibits forcible regime change.
Sanctions — or unilateral coercive measures — constitute collective punishment of the civilian population, which is prohibited by the Geneva and Hague Conventions. They also violate the Charter of the Organization of American States, which prohibits intervention in the internal or external affairs of another country and the use of economic or political coercive measures “to force the sovereign will of another State.”
Exacerbating Pandemic Suffering
The blockade has exacerbated the suffering of the Cuban people during the pandemic. Conditions are dire in Cuba. There are long lines for food, water and supplies. And a gasoline shortage caused by the blockade is preventing food grown in the countryside from reaching the market in the cities.
Speaking to protesters on July 12, Diaz-Canel explained that they have had to convert hotels to hospitals because of the spike in Covid-19 cases. This has caused electricity shortages.
Even before the pandemic, there were serious food, medical and fuel shortages. In 2020, seven UN special rapporteurs and independent experts concluded that the blockade was “obstructing humanitarian responses to help the country’s health-care system fight the Covid-19 pandemic.”
As a result of the pandemic, Cuba is unable to buy ventilators or personal protective equipment. It can’t receive financial transfers from foreign companies and humanitarian organizations. The blockade has had a “drastic effect on Cuba’s vaccine industry” by making it difficult to obtain the raw materials to make the vaccine, according to Oxfam.
“Even so, the state’s generous and long-term investment in health care and education means it was able to develop its own Covid vaccine — only to then face a shortage of syringes, the blockade making it difficult to buy them from manufacturers,” Branko Marcetic wrote at Jacobin.
In March, 80 House Democrats urged Biden to repeal the Trump administration’s “cruel policies against the Cuban people.” They told Biden that, “with the stroke of a pen, you can assist struggling Cuban families and promote a more constructive approach by promptly returning to the Obama–Biden Administration policy of engagement and normalization of relations.”
“The embargo is absurdly cruel and, like too many other U.S. policies targeting Latin Americans, the cruelty is the point,” Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-New York) said in a statement. “I outright reject the Biden administration’s defense of the embargo. It is never acceptable for us to use cruelty as a point of leverage against every day people.”
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vermont), Mexican President Andrés Manuel López Obrador and former Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva all laid the blame for the conditions in Cuba on U.S. policy.
Black Lives Matter condemned “the U.S. federal government’s inhumane treatment of Cubans” and urged it “to immediately lift the economic embargo,” which it called a “cruel and inhumane policy, instituted with the explicit intention of destabilizing the country and undermining Cubans’ right to choose their own government,” noting that it is “at the heart of Cuba’s current crisis.”
In June, for the 29th straight year, the United Nations General Assembly condemned the U.S. embargo on Cuba. The vote was 184-2. Only the United States and Israel voted against the resolution.
US Has Defended Terrorism Against Cuba
Besides its cruel blockade, the U.S. government has encouraged and facilitated terrorism against Cuba while calling Cuba a “state sponsor of terrorism.”
Since 1959, anti-Cuba terror groups based in Miami have carried out several terrorist attacks against Cuba and people who advocated normalizing relations between the U.S. and Cuba. Those terrorist organizations include the Cuban American National Foundation, Alpha 66, Commandos F4, Independent and Democratic Cuba, and Brothers to the Rescue. They have operated with impunity in the United States — with full knowledge and support of the CIA and the FBI.
Luis Posada Carriles planted a bomb on a Cubana airliner in 1976, killing all 73 persons aboard. He has never been criminally prosecuted in the United States even though declassified FBI and CIA documents at the National Security Archive show that Posada Carriles was the mastermind of the airplane bombing.
In the face of this terrorism, five men from Cuba, known as “the Cuban Five,” gathered intelligence in Miami in order to prevent future terrorist acts against Cuba. They peacefully infiltrated criminal exile groups and then turned over the results of their investigation to the FBI. But instead of working with Cuba against terrorism, the U.S. government arrested the five men.
At trial, former high-ranking U.S. military and security officials testified that Cuba posed no military threat to the United States. None of the five Cuban men had any classified material in their possession or committed any acts to injure the United States. They were nonetheless convicted in 2001 of acting as unregistered Cuban agents in the United States and of conspiracy to commit espionage. The Cuban Five were sent to prison for many years and were eventually released.
The Obama administration removed Cuba from the list of state sponsors of terrorism. But Trump added Cuba back onto the list. The 80 House members also urged Biden “to reverse the recent politicized decision by the departing Trump Administration to add Cuba back to the list of State Sponsors of Terrorism. This designation will further damage Cuba’s economy and place another roadblock in your path towards improved relations.” The letter noted that, “Cuba was removed from the list in 2015 after an exhaustive review by experts at the State Department and in the Intelligence Community, and the Trump Administration did not cite any new facts to justify their decision.” Biden says he is reviewing the designation.
It is high time for Biden to make good on his pledge to reverse Trump’s sanctions against Cuba. Congress should listen to all of the countries of the world who have repeatedly urged the lifting of the punishing blockade of Cuba. It is time to end the U.S.’s economic war on Cuba.
Marjorie Cohn is professor emerita at Thomas Jefferson School of Law, former president of the National Lawyers Guild, and a member of the bureau of the International Association of Democratic Lawyers and the advisory board of Veterans for Peace. Her books include Drones and Targeted Killing: Legal, Moral, and Geopolitical Issues.
This article is from Truthout and reprinted with permission.
The views expressed are solely those of the author and may or may not reflect those of Consortium News.
Please Support Our
Summer Fund Drive!
Since when is the US interested in alleviating Cuba’s or any other country’s lives it has under its thumb…or should I say boots??? The US is a cowardly nation…
“But they ignore or minimize the leading cause of economic suffering in Cuba: the U.S. illegal and punishing economic blockade that Biden has left in place.”
Talk about stumbling out of the gate.
Oh yea? What about the fact that Cuba freely trades with just about everyone else? QED: lack of US trade can’t be the ‘leading cause’.
So what is the ‘leading cause’? How about the oppression of the Cubans by the Cuban government, who do everything in their own self interest? That fits the bill much better, and explains all the voting-with-the-feet.
OK PointerOfTheObvious –
Why do all the Cubans in the US of A think they get to decide Cuban policy for the country as a whole?
If they want to direct policy in Cuba, why don’t they just go back there?
The bigger issue here is the way US of A policy “treats” Cuba — a sovereign country last I heard; in fact, I saw their Olympic team — is indicative of the US of A policy for the whole southern part of the America’s including Central American countries. Well, that stinking policy is truly getting old in the teeth….20th century ideas whose time ought have ended long ago because we are now in the 21st century.
The US should trade with Cuba because it would be profitable for both sides. Imagine that!
A reality check on several fronts, the causes of Cuba’s economic problems (as in the case of Venezuela, and Iran and ….) and the electoral deception of the Democratic Party that, as usual, fooled so many naïve pseudo progressives. Something to think about and more, to remember when voting during the next elections.
The next election ought be different than the last.
How about some Article V Action?
How about that?
How about we discuss this further after the Olympics. From my perspective of the countries paraded in, the folks from the southern part of the “American” continents seemed to be the most fun. I did like that fellow though who was all shined up with some sort of oil to really show off his fine form! That was good. Just can’t remember which country he was from, but I’ll figure it out.
How about Cuba gets the “right” to practice some fair competition. I’m guessing the medical establishment there could make a mint if others were allowed to utilize their skills. I plan on doing this before I die, but I might be dreaming.
OK, the 10000 meter track event is gonna be one for the memory books. That is my prediction.
Guillermo you are being too kind in your assessment of the left wing of the Democratic Party. They will never acknowledge the destruction wrought by the Castros and their successors in Cuba. Because they truly do not care about people only their ideology. Let the Cubans suffer it’s all because of the embargo. Cubans in the diaspora have sent billions of dollars over 60 years to their families with the money stolen by the Cuban government. The Democratic left in the US will never relent. This Cuban-American will never vote Democrat again.
Does the US remember any more why they have imposed these cruel, unjust sanctions on Cuba? What are the underlying reasons for these sanctions to be still in place?
The United States has become a rogue nation. An authoritarian police state. It is like the terrible two that it is – it wants whatever it wants
– it wants it, it’s way
– it throws a temper tantrum if it doesn’t get its way.
Unfortunately, letting other people decide what they want is not among its wants. It’ll handle the wants not you. Unfortunately, the US seems to be stuck in a repeat of the first part of the 20th century when the fascists and socialists battled it out for which system would be used by country X. Surely we all know where that ended up.
What will Biden do? I think I know.
I think there is going to be a new party forming soon when disillusioned ones abandon the reckless Democratic Party of empty promises.
I’m looking forward to it.
What SHOULD Biden do?
Go to prison, along with all the still living US presidents except Jimmy Carter for the crime of unprovoked siege warfare against a foreign government that the Washington regime has been plotting to bring down for sixty years. This is a crime that has been committed repeatedly against numerous other sovereign nations and, in many cases, accompanied by military invasion and wholesale slaughter of the civilian populations. The UN should do its job and bring an end to this naked attempt at global conquest. How? Every member state should throw out the American military occupiers ensconced in nearly a thousand bases around the world, bleeding them dry with simultaneous guerilla warfare if need be.
Will this happen any time soon?
Of course not. Washington’s vassals are as corrupt as it is, happy to bleed their own citizens in support of America’s global militarism, just as we tax-paying Americans are fleeced daily to support the lifestyles of the rich and powerful. At least such a revolt will have to wait until Washington is so broke from all its rapacious overreach that it cannot keep making its agreed upon bribery payments. The UN Charter has been made as meaningless as the American Constitution. Most of the provisions in both documents are routinely and flagrantly violated or ignored. Slander, lies and false narratives prevail in the General Assembly and Security Council as much as they do in Congress and the White House during our times. NATO has been transformed from a regional defense alliance against now extinct communism into Washington’s Foreign Legion which basically helps occupy invaded countries. Washington thinks this dilutes its culpability in its crimes against humanity.
What Biden should do is irrelevant at this point in time – I honestly don’t think he is making the decisions.
What I am going to do is find out even more than I already know, and so many others do as well, who is making the decisions these days, and then for the sake of my children, I’m going to do something about these poor decision makers whose brains have been filled with molasses.
I hope others do this as well and then let the chips fall where they must.
OK Realist – is this a satisfactory response? I hope it gets through.
Serious business is upon us and the reckoning is unfolding as I type.
Best to you Realist,