Jonthan Cook on the British broadcaster’s presentation of a documentary marking the one-year anniversary of the massacre of Israelis at the Nova rave.
Commemorative display of the Nova Festival at Expo Tel Aviv fairgrounds in December 2023. (Chenspec, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)
By Jonathan Cook
Jonathan-Cook.net
It says much about the institutional racism of the BBC that it thinks its Surviving October 7: We Will Dance Again is a suitable title for the documentary it aired marking the first anniversary of the massacre of Israelis at the Nova rave.
Presumably the programme-makers believed it suggested healing and empowerment for those who survived Oct. 7, rather than, as it does, continuing indifference to the horrifying plight of the people of Gaza who live — or, in so many cases, have died — just a stone’s throw from where the Nova festival was held.
At the time of the rave, Palestinians were trapped in the concentration camp of Gaza, under a medieval-style siege by land, sea and air that Israel had imposed on them for 17 years. Until, that is, Hamas broke out for one day, on Oct. 7, briefly spreading carnage in its wake.
Like most other Israelis, the partygoers at Nova either did not know or did not care that so much suffering was happening just out of view in Gaza.
They know now. As do the programme-makers.
[The documentary is also available in several countries, including the U.S., via Paramount+.]
Tens of thousands of Palestinians, most of them women and children, have been slaughtered by Israel’s bombs over the past year. The rest are being starved to death by an intensified Israeli siege.
The International Court of Justice has ruled that a “plausible” case has been made that Israel is committing a genocide. Though no Western politicians or media ever mention it, Israel is, in fact, on trial at this very moment at the world’s highest court, charged with the ultimate crime against humanity.
The International Court of Justice at The Hague, on May 24, when it ordered Israel to stop its assault on Rafah. (ICJ)
So what is the title “We will dance again” meant to convey? That Israelis can get back to partying because the deaths and suffering they experienced at Hamas’ hands lasted only a day?
There is no end in sight, even a year on, for Palestinians who have been slaughtered in far, far bigger numbers and have experienced suffering on an incomparably greater scale at Israel’s hands.
Will Israelis dance again because they still have homes and families to go back to? Whereas Palestinians have nothing. Their communities have been wiped off the face of the earth, and whole families disappeared into mass graves. Gaza’s orphans will never be reunited with their parents.
Will Israelis dance again because they have food on the table and water not only to drink but to bathe in, even swim in? Because the lights work at the touch of a switch, as do their televisions and fridges?
Gaza’s children have none of that. They must scour for whatever scraps are left, fight off the feral dogs for any tidbit they can grab, eat weeds if they can find them among the rubble.
They must walk hours or days to find water. There are no televisions or fridges. There are no walls or roofs to protect them. And without walls, there are no light switches or light fittings. And even if there were, there is no electricity to turn on. The wires are dead.
Will Israelis dance again because the BBC and the rest of the Western media are so invested in amplifying their voice, in making documentaries to record and honour their pain?
Gaza’s children have no voice. Their cries go unheard. Their tears evaporate in the summer heat, and merge with the winter rain. No one comes from outside to make a documentary about them. No one comes at all.
If Gaza’s children survive, will they ever get to dance?
Jonathan Cook is an award-winning British journalist. He was based in Nazareth, Israel, for 20 years. He returned to the U.K. in 2021.He is the author of three books on the Israel-Palestine conflict: Blood and Religion: The Unmasking of the Jewish State (2006), Israel and the Clash of Civilisations: Iraq, Iran and the Plan to Remake the Middle East (2008) and Disappearing Palestine: Israel’s Experiments in Human Despair (2008). If you appreciate his articles, please consider offering your financial support.
This article is from the author’s blog, Jonathan Cook.net.
The views expressed are solely those of the author and may or may not reflect those of Consortium News.
Please Donate Today to CN’s Fall Fund Drive
Are these the same “Dancing Israelis” we saw after the Twin Towers were struck?
The snots at the BBC now seem to have adopted the ultimate vulgar display; how does that fit in with their obvious belief in their own superiority? Hate to tell you this, but vulgarity is generally a feature of the inferior (which we all know they are). And anyone who celebrates Israel is as vulgar as they come.
Confirmation if any were needed that the British Broadcasting Corporation is primarily a propaganda organisation. They’ve lost a lot of licence payers but millions still swallow their evil bullshit. It also says a lot about the Guardian that they’re constantly going on about loving the state broadcaster.
Palestinians voted for Hamas once in 2006 and they took over from Fatah in Gaza in June 2007.
A decade later Netanyahu was bragging to his friends that Hamas was his Secret Police to control and snitch on the Palestinians in Gaza. Israel seized most of the money sent to the Palestinians and dispersed it, preferably to Hamas (who had humanitarian as well as Secret Police roles). While most of Israel did not know that Oct 7 was coming, surely Netanyahu and other higher ups knew (even the Egyptians knew and warned them); they either green-lit the hostage taking or let it happen. They sacrificed the Nova Rave people just like the Democrats sacrificed the Trumpers on January 6th. The young people at the Rave were not the ultranationalist fascist types who Israel is now built on, they were expendable, likely political opponents. Oct 7 was contrived as an excuse for wholesale ethnic cleansing of Palestinians from Israel with the US’s blessing (most likely Blinken and Sullivan and Biden also knew and approved through crocodile tears).
The insensitivity of the BBC, in making a documentary, marking the first anniversary of Oct 7, in the midst of an ongoing genocide, is grotesque. What was in the minds of the programme-makers when they set about making such a documentary? They certainly didn’t take into account the continuing suffering of the Palestinians.
The BBC has been accused by its own journalists of failing to report the Israeli- Palestinian conflict accurately and investing greater effort in humanising Israeli victims compared with Palestinians. This documentary is a further example of such indifference.
Jonathan Cook is a timely candidate for the first international Julian Assange Prize for Noble Journalism!
Thank You Jonathan
I wonder, when will the people in Asheville dance again ….
hxxps://statuscoup.substack.com/p/the-stench-is-unbearable-dead-bodies
It’s bad enough that we not only don’t give a damn about the atrocities our Gov.t is funding against people “over there”, we don’t even give a damn about people over here – sending our “National Guard” to Kuwait instead of NC …
What does this say about our “priorities”?
When are we going to get really angry about our “Gov’t” – What will it take …
All things are connected …
Totally agree, SH, and it is monstrous that Americans could never put two + two together. I’ve talked to way too many people who seem to think it’s fine to invade, bomb, and steal from other countries, and I doubt they once dreamed that someday “their” government would come for them. Until people realize they have nothing to lose — no food, no water, no home — they will just sit back and do nothing.
Agree with the other comments. Wonderful article, but do wish people would stop using the word, “massacre” when referring to Oct 7 for two reasons. One is that the Palestinians have been massacred for over 75 years. Also, the Israelis killed were many IDF soldiers, and many of the rest were killed by the IDF. The Hannibal Directive applies to captured Israeli civilians, as well as captured IDF soldiers. I heard Kamala Harris lie again the other day about “rapes” which has been proven did not happen by the Palestinians, but happens every day by the IDF. She never mentions that.
Given the Australian ABC’s historic links to, and reliance for content on, the BBC, it is probably considering purchasing or running this documentary. Based only on Jonathon Cook’s assessment, I hope it decides not to take that path. However given our broadcaster’s caving in to the disproportionately powerful Jewish lobby it will probably get a run.
Zionist lobby, not Jewish.
There is a coded message in this too, a reminder of the “Dancing Israelis” caught on the morning of 9/11 celebrating the destruction in New York City.
No, Israelis will not dance again. They and the Western empire that birthed Israel will never recover from what they have done. The rest of the world is repulsed and horrified at seeing the true nature of this decrepit dying empire. May we all survive its welcome demise.
Trust the bloody “british bullshit corporation” to come up with some distasteful documentary like this.
Britain has gone from being the 51st State to just another Israeli kibbutz …