Are You Human Like Us?

A hunger for genocide and ethnic cleansing colours senior Israeli officials’ statements and has influenced their conduct in this war. Talk of civilian casualties is brushed off, and so are calls for a ceasefire, writes Vijay Prashad.

By Vijay Prashad
Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research

More than 10,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli armed forces in Gaza since Oct. 7, nearly half of them children, according to the most recent report by spokesperson for the Gaza Ministry of Health Dr Ashraf Al-Qudra. Over 25,000 others have been injured, with thousands still buried under the rubble.

Meanwhile, Israeli tanks have begun to encircle Gaza City, whose population was 600,000 a month ago but whose neighbourhoods are now largely vacant due to the desperate flight of its inhabitants to Gaza’s southern shelters and due to Israel’s killing of thousands of Palestinian civilians in their homes.

Israel has cut off the city and begun to raid it, going door to door to bring the terror of the occupation from the skies to the streets. Those who await these raids in their homes might whisper the poem of Mahmoud Darwish (1941–2008), which is addressed to the Israeli soldier ready to kick down the door of a Palestinian home:

You there, by the threshold of our door,
come in and drink Arabic coffee with us
(you may feel that you are human like us)
You there, by the threshold of our door,
get out of our mornings
so that we may be assured that
we are humans like you

When Israeli soldiers begin going door to door there will be no time for coffee, not only because there is no coffee or water left, but because Israeli soldiers have been told that Palestinians are not human. They have been told, instead, that Palestinians are terrorists and animals. In the eyes of the occupying forces, the only treatment Palestinians deserve is to be assaulted, shot, killed, and eradicated altogether.

A hunger for genocide and ethnic cleansing colours senior Israeli officials’ statements and has influenced their conduct in this war. Talk of civilian casualties is brushed off, and so are calls for a ceasefire. The spokesperson of the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) James Elder said of this situation: ‘Gaza has become a graveyard for thousands of children. It’s a living hell for everyone else’.

Laila Shawa (Palestine), Target 2009, 2009.

Even when high-ranking U.S. officials talk about a ‘humanitarian pause’, they continue to find billions of dollars and more weapons systems for the Israeli military. This idea of a ‘humanitarian pause’ is legalese that means nothing for the survival of Gazans: the pause would end the bombing for a short period of time, possibly only a few hours, to allow the wounded to be removed and some aid to enter Gaza City before giving Israelis a green light to resume their murderous bombardment.

Thus far, Israel has dropped a higher tonnage of explosives on Gaza than the combined weight of the two bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945.

The denial of both a ceasefire and the possibility of political talks sponsored by the U.N. is not a policy that the U.S. is pushing in Palestine alone; it is the same policy that the U.S., alongside its partners in the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO), have insisted upon in Ukraine. A new supplemental spending bill that totals $105 billion (in addition to the – likely underreported – $858-billion military budget for 2023) includes $61.4 billion for the grinding war in Ukraine and $14.1 billion for the Israeli genocide of the Palestinians.

Though peace talks opened between Ukrainian and Russian authorities in both Belarus and Turkey days after Russian troops entered Ukraine, these talks were hastily scuttled by NATO, fuelling the conflict that has resulted in nearly 10,000 civilian deaths so far. The civilian death toll in Ukraine during one year and eight months of the conflict has already been surpassed by the civilian death toll in Palestine in merely four weeks.

Belkis Ayon (Cuba), La cena (‘The Supper’), 1991.

It is not a coincidence that these three countries – the U.S., Ukraine, and Israel – are the only ones that did not vote in favour of this year’s annual U.N. General Assembly resolution to end the six-decade-long U.S. embargo on Cuba (which was imposed formally by U.S. President John F. Kennedy on Feb. 3, 1962 but began in 1960). The U.S. has not only enforced this blockade on Cuba as a country, but on the Cuban Revolution as a process.

When the Cuban Revolution of 1959 emphatically declared that it would defend the sovereignty of Cuban territory and advance the dignity of the Cuban people, the U.S. saw it as a threat not only to its criminal interests on the island but also to its ability to maintain its grip over global affairs, which the potential contagion of the revolutionary process threatened to fracture.

If Cuba could get away with looking after its own people, and even extending solidarity to others fighting for their right to do the same, before submitting to the demands of U.S.-owned transnational corporations, then perhaps other countries could adopt a similar attitude. It was this fear of sovereignty that set the policy of the blockade in motion.

Though the blockade has cost the Cuban Revolution hundreds of billions of dollars since 1960, it has not been able to stop the revolution from building up people’s dignity. For example, the World Bank reported that in 2020, despite the harsh blockade and the COVID-19 pandemic, Cuba’s government spent 11.5 percent of its Gross Domestic Product on education, while the U.S. spent 5.4 percent. Not only are all schools free for Cuban children, but all Cuban children receive meals at school and are given their uniforms.

Medical education is also free in Cuba, creating a high doctor-to-patient ratio of 8.4 physicians and 7.1 nurses for every 1,000 Cubans. At the U.N. General Assembly, Cuba’s Foreign Minister Bruno Rodríguez Parrilla said that ‘attention to the human being has been and will continue to be the priority of the Cuban government’. The blockade might be ‘economic warfare’, he said, but the Cuban Revolution – which has faced this ‘economic siege’ for decades – will not wilt. It will stand firm.

Raúl Martínez (Cuba), Rosas y Estrellas (‘Roses and Stars’), 1972.

The blockade is cruel. Foreign Minister Rodríguez Parrilla offered some examples of that cruelty, such as when the U.S. government prevented Cuba from importing pulmonary ventilators and medical oxygen (including from other Latin American countries). In response, Cuba’s scientists and engineers developed their own ventilators, just as they produced their own COVID-19 vaccines.

During the pandemic, Rodríguez Parrilla said, the U.S. government offered humanitarian exemptions to other countries but denied them to Cuba. “The reality,” he said, “is that the U.S. government opportunistically used COVID-19 as an ally in its hostile policy toward Cuba.”

Darwish asks Israeli soldiers of humanity, of whether they are capable of seeing Palestinians as human. The same should be asked of U.S. government officials who promote and prosecute the blockade on Cuba: do they see Cubans as human?

Tings Chak (China), Palestine Will Be Free, 2023.

In June of this year, the Paris Poetry Market invited the Cuban poet Nancy Morejón to be its 2023 honorary president. Just before the event, the organisers of the poetry festival cancelled this honour, saying that they were responding to ‘pressures’ and ‘rumours’. The Cuban foreign ministry condemned this cancellation as part of the ‘siege of fascist hatred of Cuban culture’, another kind of blockade.

Here is Nancy Morejón’s Réquiem para la mano izquierda (‘Requiem for the Left Hand’), as if in conversation with the humaneness of Darwish’s poetry and with the rhythms of the Cuban musician Marta Valdés (to whom this poem is dedicated):

On a map you could trace all the lines
horizontal, vertical, diagonal
from the Greenwich meridian to the Gulf of Mexico
that more or less
belong to our peculiarity

There are also big, big, big maps
in your imagination
and endless globes of the Earth,

But today I suspect that the tiniest, most minute map
sketched on school notebook paper
would be big enough to fit all of history
All of it.



12 comments for “Are You Human Like Us?

  1. Drew Hunkins
    November 13, 2023 at 10:49

    Forgot the apostrophe

    Edit: Over 80% of Israeli Jews think Palestinians’ rights and needs should not be taken into consideration whatsoever.

  2. November 13, 2023 at 04:49

    Israel is just following orders from the god of The Bible:

    “As for the cities of these peoples that the Lord your God is going to give you as an inheritance, you must not allow a single living thing to survive. Instead you must utterly annihilate them — the Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites [primary ancestors of Palestinians], Perizzites, Hivites, and Jebusites [the people of Jerusalem]” (Deuteronomy 20:16-17).

    2.4 billion Christians also worship that god as the Father component of their tripartite deity – Father, Son & Holy Ghost. Many people think that the tail (Israel) is wagging the dog (Western Civilization), but the dog regrew the tail in 1948.

  3. November 12, 2023 at 14:39

    There are no Hamas in the West Bank! There is, however 1 trillion cubic meters of untapped liquefied natural gas that Chevron has permits to drill once the Palestinians are removed

  4. Maria Gerber
    November 11, 2023 at 13:22

    Emailing and calling Bernie Sanders’ office to express disgust and horror at his stance on Gaza. RFK Jr.’s campaign does not have a phone number, so I am leaving messages at Children’s Health Defense instead. The posturing as a moral man had so many of us hoodwinked. How does the man who started CHD NOT defend the children of Gaza? SICKENING!!!!!

  5. Rudy Haugeneder
    November 11, 2023 at 13:12

    With a tiny few exceptions, Sapiens are subhuman.

  6. Selina Sweet
    November 11, 2023 at 11:50

    Powerful new images. Thanks!

  7. Selina Sweet
    November 11, 2023 at 11:49

    What drives this maniacal fixation on “elimination” of the “other”?
    Such rage and fear against the “unacceptable.” Projected outward.
    The inner unacceptable “animal” of the Israeli. The “in-human and non-human”.
    How do you reconcile being the “chosen” people out of all the rest with
    what you sense is inside but never explore?
    Bulwark’s against the unacceptable within. All that energy has to go somewhere.
    For the mythologists, who is Netanyahu?
    A wise man talked about the split. About those conditioned in religious systems of all good and all bad – with no in-between.
    What must one do if you are of a people “chosen” by God, when you know you have inside badness?

  8. November 11, 2023 at 11:17

    This moving article covers many topics, all, unfortunately related. On this “Veterans’ Day”, the holiday which since 1947 replaced Armistice Day in the United States, it is worth reflecting on the reality that peace and justice and equity and democracy and liberty are only aspirations in a world ruled by and for the very few.

  9. Couldbe
    November 11, 2023 at 06:23

    “Are You Human Like Us?”

    Israel and The United States of America’s sustainability depends upon other’s belief in their “powers” internally and externally.

    The activities of Hamas and others on the borders of Israel have further undermined the beliefs of others and hence this partly explains the responses of Israel, whilst the challenges of the “powers” of The United States of America throughout the world in various presentations receive similar vindictive reactions.

  10. Jeff Harrison
    November 11, 2023 at 00:30

    Yeah. I think the world is still dealing with the colonial mindset of “The West”

    • Couldbe
      November 12, 2023 at 05:43

      ” I think the world is still dealing with the colonial mindset of “The West”

      Colonialism continues to be a culture of rent seeking by “the West”, a synonym of “The United States of America” which requires various form of coercion to facilitate, ergo practices of win/lose and contingent constant “war” in various presentations.

      Consequently the rest of the world are engaged in various presentations to transcend that culture by cooperative relationships based on mutual benefit, ergo practices of win/win, and hence pose an existential threat to colonialism and the continued sustainability of “The West”, the challenges of the “powers” of “The United States of America” throughout the world in various presentations receive similar vindictive reactions encouraging the rest of the world to increase their cooperative endeavours to transcend “the West”.

  11. Share
    November 10, 2023 at 18:39

    I called my congressional representative today and requested they stop funding the genocide. My last words were, “They ARE human, you know.”

Comments are closed.