Easter Hope: Justice Against Torture

From the Archive: Celebrating Easter in 2009, ex-CIA analyst Ray McGovern saw progress toward ending the Iraq War and hope that George W. Bush and other U.S. war criminals might finally face justice. Three years later, however, many of those dreams of accountability remain unfulfilled.

By Ray McGovern (Originally published April 8, 2009)

In 2006, Easter dawned in Crawford, Texas, for the many friends of peace gathered to celebrate new Easter hope. Rev. Joseph Lowery gave an inspired message that morning, in what turned out to be a warm-up for his Benediction at the Inauguration of President Barack Obama in January 2009.

Camp Casey that Easter 2006 was a relatively quiet occasion to reflect and celebrate new life and one another. The best known resident of Crawford had decided to avoid the crowd assembling there, opting instead to spend Easter at Camp David, where troublesome questioners could be kept even farther away. People like Cindy Sheehan who would not stop asking why our sons and daughters were being killed and maimed in an unnecessary war in Iraq.

President George W. Bush in a poster by Robbie Conal (robbieconal.com)

The previous summer, Sheehan had become the Rosa Parks of Crawford, challenging President George W. Bush to tell her what was the “noble cause” for which her son Casey died on April 4, 2004. Sadly, we were not surprised that an answer-less President preferred clearing brush to clearing up what he meant by saying such deaths were “worth it.”

Ironically, President Bush seemed supremely comfortable talking about evildoers, other evildoers. We, in contrast, saw evil in the launching of what the post-WWII Nuremberg Tribunal labeled a “war of aggression,” defined as the “supreme international crime, differing from other war crimes only in that it contains the accumulated evil of the whole.”

As I gathered with other pilgrims in Crawford those sad summers of 2005 and 2006, there was a strong sense of responsibility to confront “the accumulated evil of the whole”, and particularly torture.

In August 2006, the timid journalists of the western White House told us the President had sweat on his brow from clearing brush. And as we gathered one evening, someone quoted from the musical Camelot:  “I wonder what the (self-styled) king is doing tonight; what merriment is the king pursuing tonight.”

With the damning disclosures about the torture procedures unleashed by that President, it seems a good guess that, rather than making merry, he was sweating the evenings away as well. You see, President Bush had left his fingerprints on accumulated evils for which he was likely to be held accountable, in one way or another. And during the summer of 2006 the chickens were coming home to roost.

On June 29 of that year, in a 5-to-3 decision, the Supreme Court ruled that the Bush administration could not deny detainees the protections afforded by the Geneva Conventions, as the President had done by executive order of Feb. 7, 2002. Worse still from Bush’s point of view, Justice Anthony Kennedy saw fit to say the obvious; i.e., that to disregard Geneva amounts to a war crime.

So as we stood watch in Crawford in 2006, gallons of sweat were being poured into an (ultimately successful) effort to get the Republican-controlled Congress to pass a law applying retroactively, that’s right, retroactively, holding everyone, from the President on down, harmless for the illegal detainment and mistreatment of detainees.

Too clever by half; it’s not going to work. On Dec. 11, 2008, Sen. John McCain and Sen. Carl Levin released the summary of a Senate Armed Services Committee report, issued without dissent, demonstrating that Bush’s Executive Order of Feb. 7, 2002, had “opened the way to considering aggressive techniques.”

And a report of the International Committee of the Red Cross not only recounts in gory detail the torture of so-called “high-value” detainees, but also puts the final nail in the coffin, so to speak, for any plans the former President may have had to travel abroad. Even if our own government proves too timid to bring him to justice, Bush cannot risk being apprehended abroad, brought to The Hague, and tried for war crimes.

Rev. Lowery’s sermon to the gathering alongside Prairie Chapel Road just three years ago rings ever more true: “Don’t tell me Easter’s not real! Don’t tell me righteousness will not overcome evil! Thy kingdom come on earth as it is in heaven. That’s the message of Easter.”

Let the church say Amen.

Ray McGovern served as an Army intelligence officer and a CIA analyst for almost 30 years. He believes anthropologist Margaret Meade had it exactly right (and that the Crawford Peace House did well to adopt her dictum): “Never doubt the power of a small group of committed individuals to change the world. It is the only thing that ever has.”

2 comments for “Easter Hope: Justice Against Torture

  1. Hillary
    April 9, 2012 at 10:53

    Excellent comment except for that Chauncy Gardner bit at the end.

  2. elmerfudzie
    April 8, 2012 at 20:31

    It’s been said before but I’ve got to say it again. The Bush’s are an anathema to the new real politique. They belong to a club, who’s members are the well known super rich of this world. The membership can be collectively referred to as the Big Finance and Speculators Club (BFSC). I exclude from this unsavory group the deservedly rich: inventors, brilliant artisans, the wildcatters who finally hit that big one, family farmers who expanded their labors and increased land value through each hard working generation (beef, grain, soybean and so on). But now comes a new sort of leadership and in particular I mean political. Building fortune on subterfuge, murder, Ponzi schemes, speculation and insider knowledge. Their shamelessness is universal, indeed global! Their implacable ignorance, is like a “mark of Cain”, tho elected, oblivious to voter needs. Just as an example; let’s look at some recent history, Ehud Barak. He purchased an apartment, yes I said, apartment, in Tel Aviv for over twenty million dollars while Israeli citizens with MD degrees were cleaning out toilets to make ends meet. This error was repeated when Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu entered the scene, another billionaire with high class property in NYC whilst his citizenry are so destitute they need a rubber check from Uncle Sam (hundreds of millions a year). We in the USA have the same outrageous amoral characters in public office. Most are born with the silver spoon, own several mansions, palatial summer homes, were always assured of an eastern establishment education or a top ten school of their choice. Some our our purple cloth politicians came into new money through usury, speculation, cooking the books, insider trading or downright deceit. I chose the Israeli example because theirs is arguably in a stable democracy, are by far the most educated and well read citizenry vis-a-vis Iceland (OH! let’s not bring up Iceland!). This did not stop the existence, predations or even influence the BFSC club. That filthy rich, former president Clinton will never know of or see the beggars on street corners I see on a daily basis, holding signs that say “I’ll work or food or “please! fifty cents, I got to get home”. I suppose Clinton can Google Earth to street level it, but it wont give give the same impression and it’s a lesson too late for the ex-prez. His rather distinctive Rhodes scholar education didn’t do a damn thing for our poor. In fact his charitable organization was gleaning off mucho dolares supposedly to help the impoverished Haitians. Besides, Americans are about to repeat the same error Israeli voters made with electing the likes of Netanyahu. Perhaps that’s what the bible passage meant when the inspired author wrote: Let the weed and wheat grow together until harvest, then the chaff will be separated out, bundled and then burned. We can only deduce that, the weed will continue to grow strong in this world of ours, cause a shadow to fall on the wheat, their roots denied soil nutrient and thus loss of life’s great potentials and growth.

Comments are closed.