Alastair Crooke: The Crisis of Trump’s War Overreach

From the streets of Paris to the Strait of Hormuz, Western liberal economies are caught in a trap of their own making.

Police in Paris firing tear gas during clashes with protesters at Porte Saint-Martin on Oct. 17. (Jules*/Wikimedia Commons/CC BY-SA 4.0)

By Alastair Crooke
Forum Geopolitica 

Almost everywhere there is a deepening sense that the Western liberal economic project is on the verge of collapsing in very fundamental ways — most obviously, this has been on display on the streets of Paris. 

But it can be seen too in the U.S. where President Donald Trump’s embrace of the Iran war seemingly has prejudiced the Republican chances in next month’s midterms. No one can guess how Trump will choose to govern, should voters turn against him personally; however an angry, frustrated and erratic presidency is most likely for the next two years.

Perhaps key to understanding today’s European turmoil occurred in 2024: The French electoral cycle had begun with a European Parliament vote, where the Right-leaning, National Rally (RN), led by Marine Le Pen had won a decisive victory. The RN won 30 seats (31.37 percent of the vote) with the Ensemble (President Emmanuel Macron’s coalition) winning only 13 seats (14.6 percent of the vote).

Following the severe defeat of his centrist coalition, Macron immediately dissolved the French National Assembly and triggered a snap domestic election. That snap election resulted in an unprecedented hung parliament divided into three main political blocs, with no single group capturing the 289 seats required for an absolute majority. It was and remained a deadlock

Whilst Le Pen’s National Rally led the first round of voting, tactical dropouts in the second round by centrist and left-wing candidates shifted the final landscape through a (legitimate) “hack” of tactical voting in seats designed to ensure that RN would not win the final round, despite leading in the first round voting. 

The recent violent unrest in Paris is linked to those 2024 French election results. The election engineered a fractured, deadlocked Parliament that Macron hoped to manipulate.  This fuelled deepening public anger at the European ruling élite’s refusal to accept accountability for the mistakes that had led to the wider European economic crisis. 

Tensions Reaching Zenith

Trump overseeing attacks on Iran at Mar-a-Lago, Palm Beach, Florida, on Feb. 28. (White House / Daniel Torok)

Key aspects of France’s crisis — out-of-control immigration, failing public services and growing cost of living pressures — are common to virtually all major liberal economies. In short, though the economic problems associated with Western states may appear to each have their unique national characteristics, they all have deeper roots that lie with the financialised Western response to the Great Financial Crisis of 2008. 

The point now is that these contradictions and tensions are reaching their zenith through the related interlinked conflicts in Ukraine, Iran and Yemen-Saudi that now risk taking the economic crisis to an altogether different level of financial crisis — one that could end in systemic breakdown. 

Pushing the crisis to climax arises from the pursuit of two contradictory objectives at the same time — firstly, the maintenance of costly welfare states, whilst secondly indulging in wars intended to maintain the Western place, per U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, at the “head of the world.” It is these wars that — predictably enough — have caused the soaring costs of living that are breaking the budget of most liberal economic states. 

Trump’s error of judgment in starting a war against Iran has catapulted cost-of- living pressures markedly higher, through soaring fuel and energy prices, which, in turn, have put sustained upward pressure on interest rates and the bond market. 

Trump’s continuing (albeit vacillating hot and cold) with the Ukraine war — and with the funding burden shifted to Europe — has simply bust through European fiscal budget limits.

Fiscal pressures are apparent everywhere, in Europe and beyond, eating deep into other forms of public expenditure, such as education and medical provision. At the same time, great swathes of Europe’s industrial heartlands have been laid waste. Unemployment, particularly among the young, has exploded. Germany alone has shed close to half a million industrial jobs in the past six years. Neither Europe, nor the U.S., is today generally price competitive. Energy inflation has put many global export markets beyond reach.

The political class throughout the Western world have legitimacy poll numbers circling the drain. Popular despair and anger are growing. Resentment seethes. It has exploded first in France, but others will experience it next.

The crisis is coming to late fruition. Iran and Ansar Allah have snapped shut their energy trap on Trump. There are no easy or obvious exits to this. In fact, if mishandled through U.S. or Israeli military escalation, war will compound the Western economic crisis dramatically, as Iran retaliates against Gulf energy infrastructure. 

And given the long timelines involved in any re-building of highly complex oil infrastructure, it is certain that a structural fuel shortfall will ratchet into escalating damage to global supply lines. The same applies for Ansar Allah’s attacks on Saudi energy infrastructure.

European Misreading of Russia

German naval officers keeping watch from a German Navy frigate during NATO exercises in July 2026 in the Baltic Sea. (NATO/Flickr/CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

In the case of Ukraine, European habitual misreading of Russia has taken Europe into a trap of their own volition. In 2022, the European leadership embraced

Ukraine and its president, Volodymyr Zelensky, seeing Ukraine as a putative norms-based liberal project, potentially giving to Europe the absent meaning and purpose to both NATO and the EU. Of course, the prospect that the European sanctions siege might ultimately dislodge Russian President Vladimir Putin from power — though misjudged — offered the glittering prospect of opening Russian oil and rare materials to European exploitation.

“The practical effect of all this,” writes Aurelien,  “was that Europe became increasingly eager to colonise a political space that had historically been controlled by Russia” but which would be now folded into the expanding liberal “space” lying to the west of Russia. Russian hostility towards these explicit European ambitions was attributed tendentiously to Russia’s nostalgia for its empire.

Yet, as Aurelien observes,  

“Russians didn’t see the period after the mid-1990s like that at all. What they saw was loss of control of what had previously been precious strategic space, with no obvious way to recover it. This is why ideas of ‘cease-fires’ and some geographical division of Ukraine haven’t got, and won’t get, anywhere. The game has moved on, and the stakes are much higher than they were. In 2022, the Russians would probably have accepted a genuinely neutral Ukraine, with no stationed forces and with nationalist extremists excluded from government.

 “There’s no chance of that now, and I interpret the current bombardment of Kiev as part of an operational-level strategy to destroy the country as a viable entity — such that it cannot be used in the future as a base for military operations. Bridges, communication systems, ports, electricity generation and distribution, transport networks, industrial facilities and airports, among others, will be destroyed … There’s no sign the West understands this. They won’t — because they don’t realise that Russian strategy has gone far beyond Ukraine now — and is about banishing the spectre of a potential attack from the ‘space’ to the West of Russia for at least a generation, maybe more.” 

This is the trap that exists and which links all the seemingly separate conflicts — the ambition for the West to “maintain its place at the head of the world” launched from a reality of decline and “bust” fiscal budgets.

The Ukraine project has hit a wall; not just on the battlefield, but because Europe is financially “broke.”  There is no way Europe can cough up another $155 billion.

Equally, there is no way Western liberal welfare economies can survive prolonged war on Iran and the Houthis. Europeans are staring at the economic abyss. Is the West ready to compound the risk of violent revolution simply to escape having to capitulate to Iran or Russia? 

Alastair Crooke is director and founder of Conflicts Forum, based in Beirut. He was formerly advisor on Middle East issues to Javier Solana, the EU foreign policy chief. 

This article was originally published on Forum Geopolitica.  It also appears on Strategic Culture Foundation.

The views expressed are solely those of the author and may or may not reflect those of Consortium News.

11 comments for “Alastair Crooke: The Crisis of Trump’s War Overreach”

  1. Annette M.
    October 30, 2026 at 15:29

    Empires rise and fall. Narratives come and go. Yet the deeper task remains unchanged: to build right human relationships across the globe and create conditions in which life can flourish.
    Beyond every struggle lies a greater possibility: the recognition that humanity is one life, expressing through many peoples, nations and cultures.
    Increasingly, people everywhere are growing weary of conflict, division and endless cycles of war. Perhaps this weariness itself reflects an awakening to a fundamental reality: that we belong to one another, and that our wellbeing is inseparable from the wellbeing of the whole.

    We are one human race, and across nations and cultures a growing recognition of our shared humanity is quietly emerging. This is both heartening and encouraging to witness. Yet wherever the illusion of separateness continues to influence human affairs, particularly through unenlightened leadership, conflict will continue to find fertile ground. More than ever, the movement towards greater unity calls for leaders of integrity, wisdom and genuine service, capable of placing the common good above personal, ideological or national interests.

    The challenge before us is not merely political or economic. It is for more of us to recognise, and ultimately live the truth of our essential unity. ??

    • Neil
      October 31, 2026 at 17:35

      Beautifully put. Thank you. -N

  2. Sailab
    October 29, 2026 at 14:18

    Alastair Crooke asks: “Is the West ready to compound the risk of violent revolution simply to escape having to capitulate to Iran or Russia?”
    The simple answer is yes, it is. If the past behaviour of Western elites is any indication of what lies ahead, can anyone imagine them suddenly realising that they should give in to Iran and Russia, of all countries, to avoid compounding the risk of violent revolution?
    When Boris Johnson was tasked with torpedoing the Istanbul peace agreement between Russia and Ukraine; when the gas pipelines connecting Russia to Europe were blown to smithereens beneath the European seas; when the president of a sovereign country was kidnapped by the US; when the US and Israel launched a blitz in the middle of “negotiations”, aimed at wiping out Iran’s leadership, along with numerous scientists and innocent civilians, and destroying the Islamic Republic and with that the country itself; and when the entire Western establishment, in one way or another, supported these atrocities, with some even celebrating them, did the West consider the consequences of these unbelievable actions?
    When Western elites lined up behind Israel as it murdered tens of thousands of Palestinians, did they consider the risks they were taking?
    Yes, this generation of Western politicians has shown that it is prepared to go all the way, even to the point of compounding the risk of violent revolution, rather than capitulating to Iran and Russia.
    Having gone through these experiences, one would think that the West needs some fresh blood—perhaps a lot of fresh blood: a new generation of elites and politicians with the vision to recognise that the world is changing and that, in this changing world, Asia has a prominent place, whether they like it or not.

    • Dr. Hujjatullah M.H.Babu Sahib
      November 1, 2026 at 06:42

      Yours is a geopolitically-sensible intellectual complement to Crooke’s highly responsible reflective piece on the political reappraisals fermenting from ground up within the broader West. Western masses are rapidly wiseing up to the misrule of their countries by the hedonistic elites in their societies. The apogee for them is symbolically Trump, who is willingly entrapped, between pursuing either tactical nuclear bombs or partaking strategic unclear bums, by the Epstein class ! But his Sec. of State is more professional, in lieu of unclear bums he is totally focused on “head of the world”. But as you have superlatively alluded to here, even Rubio’s focal-sharpness will have difficulty extricating the U.S. head from the geopolitical bums in which it is entrapped !

    • common sense
      November 1, 2026 at 15:44

      Well stated ^^

  3. common sense
    October 29, 2026 at 12:07

    “Western liberal welfare economies”-

    Unlimited welfare only for the very few.

    Austerity for the majority to pay for it.

    This is naked fascism/ capitalism.

  4. Andrew Nichols
    October 28, 2026 at 23:44

    The Euro political class will do a false flag and then invoke Article 5 to start WW3 in earnest, rather than pull their heads in and make peace with Russia. Europe desparately needs Serbian style regime change. This is why the crackdowns on the French and Italian studdnt led protests will get increasingly violent. The media are already manufacturing consent for this.

  5. wildthange
    October 28, 2026 at 19:00

    The wars for military arms spending to prop up our deficit spending warfare technology system requiring test wars is coming up against all manner or irrational sanctions applied to the world economy plus outright tariff attacks on friends and foes alike is stressing the US/NATO full spectrum dominance system into blatant immorality for western torture of global life including ignoring the inflationary cost of climate impacts and wasted resources on strategic military addiction out of touch with our century.

  6. Tiller
    October 28, 2026 at 16:55

    Whether Europeans or Americans do'” surely realize” they are being corralled into a horrifyingly undesirable war ( WW3, really)to preserve a civilization of, by and for the ultra rich and unscrupulous; and wherever in the empire that increasingly risky brinksmanship type war war happens to be, the citizens power to change that insane choice is crippled by political structures that show no interest in citizen concerns. Some think the kind of riots we see now in Europe and that brothers in resistance like Chris Hedges propose as a strategy in the US can overturn this entrenched systemic, police and surveillance reinforced arrangement and build an alternative political common ground. I deeply hope the French and Italians etc. can show the path to such change, but forgive me for being skeptical on several fronts. Not least the simple likelihood that anger and disruption will not suffice, that thousands will continue to be jailed, and harsh measures increase, , false flags and agent provocateurs used to justify state violence, until the unrest recedes and protestors are targeted by surveillance and harassment. Also electoral solidarity for real change is still rather remote. There is little clarity of alternative vision. The movement of mainstream institutions toward fascism has its own momentum and Gaza indicates that there are no limits to that intention.

    There are bigger issues also driving global instability. Too many analysts are willfully ignoring the climate crisis even as its effects grow and are likely to escalate through heated oceans, receding ice, methane and other feedback loops. The death tolls are rising, whole major river systems devastated, fires rage throughout the earth, unreliable coasts, rising costs and risks to food production and effectively negative progress on emissions reductions. In this scenario despite what seem to be more balanced and humane benefits from economic growth among BRICS affiliated nations, their economic models are not honestly addressing climate change either.

    Another issue is the digital surveillance state and the growing threat of fascist technocracy managed by our newest electronic invasive species. AI is a weapon of war against the ideal of consensual, informed openly debated and balanced self government and human rights. Rubio, Musk, Thiel are telling us where they want to go and the markets are betting on fascism. The eyes of big brother are everywhere.

    The largest vulnerability of the West is debt and untrustworthiness. Only those in the subservient billionaire class are successfully being blackmailed into preparing for WW3. The rest are fighting back, being strangled, or adopting an every-nation-for-itself mode of operating often fostering their own internal cruelties , and tensions.

    None of this, despite its end of the world drama, is seriously debatable; and together it portrays a level of destabilization that our collective civilization is utterly unprepared for. But a needed first step is to admit that the fascism of the axis powers has never really been an abhorrent and defeated force of the past. It represents the human addiction to power as it manifests in modern technology, modern economic and military war and fossil fuel driven civilization. Since WW2 that addiction and model of power has simply taken new forms: The CIA and US militarism, the Stalinist police state, the War on Terror, the cult of secrecy in centers of power, the plunder of poor nations benefitting the ruthless subverters of democratic process and fostering ever more military dictators , the corruption of media to dominate the political landscape, the growth of monopolies at the expense of fair competition, the human addiction to messiah like promises divorced from justice or ecological sanity.
    Humans are perfectly capable of better relations with each other and with our living planet. (see David Gaeber and David Wengrows The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humaniity Only)And Our numbers are on our side on a great many key issues, but we are going to continue to lose that potential power as long as we are too divided over trivial issues to unite around shared sensible alternatives. Our common ground is everywhere, the air we breathe, the food we need, the love of friends and family, the truths we find in science and spirit, the clarity of a history that tells us we reap what we sow.

    • Hujjathullah M.H.B. Sahib
      November 1, 2026 at 07:00

      What a way to crisply capture the whole gamut of the existential abyss into which the privilegedly miseducated neo-liberal morons of the West are taking humanity to ! They lectured the world on reigning in global-warming and yet proceeded to either jet away brainlessly across the world or put the world itself under increasing bombardments. This is clearly hypocrisy writ large and attempting to get it globally institutionalized too even under duress !

  7. Rob Roy
    October 28, 2026 at 15:23

    Putin said that anyone who doesn’t regret the breakup of the USSR has no heart, but anyone who wants it back has no brains. The last thing the Russian Federation wants is to expand West. He must stay in office, being the most trustworthy president on earth. He stopped the Nazis killing of Russian speakers in the Donbas, kept Crimea, and will keep out the American war machine, NATO. Now Crimea is a Russian Republic, as are the oblasts in the Donbas. BTW, you’re one of my go-to reporters on world events. Thanks for continuing to speak.

Comments are closed.