If the streets of France have something important to tell us now, it is that the centrist, or liberal-authoritarian, model is crumbling as surely as the lycées of Lyons and Nimes.

Police at a student protest in Perpignan, France, on Oct. 2. (Aurelio Cárdenas /Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)
By Patrick Lawrence
Special to Consortium News
The French have had a certain gift for street demonstrations going back to July 14, 1789, when they stormed the Bastille and the monarchy’s subjects began to make themselves, that semi-sacred word, citoyens.
Now they are out in force once again, this time led by high school students whose grievances run to broken windows, crumbling classrooms, absentee teachers, and poor education altogether.
They often start small, these waves of national protest. The memorable évènements of May 1968 began over outdated academic standards, overcrowded classrooms and prudish dormitory visitation rules. Proposed increases in diesel fuel sparked the “yellow vest” demonstrations of 2018–2020.
And now it is France’s decrepit lycées, where neglect and disrepair seem to be the national norm.
But how often do small, local grievances prove merely sparks that ignite prairie fires, as we Americans would put it. May ’68 was about far more than fusty rules and remote, inaccessible professors. It was about the social and political order and, so, it was about power.
It was the same with the gilets jaunes protests. They were about neoliberal austerity and Emmanuel Macron as “president of the rich.” So they were about power, too.
The hundreds of thousands of students who began protesting conditions in high schools across the country have stayed “on message” since they took to the streets several weeks ago. The lousy conditions in which they get their lousy educations remain the focus as these demonstrations have spread to major cities — Marseilles, Strasbourg, Toulouse, Tours, et al. —as well as many towns and rural villages.
But as students, parents, some school administrators and some teachers are joined by national unions, opposition parties, working professionals and government officials, it is obvious the broken windows, falling plaster and teachers who don’t show up are, while justified sources of outrage, also signifiers of larger grievances.
What is at issue across France is the liberal-authoritarian model, which is now known in polite company as “centrist” even if this is not the center of anything. And if the streets of France have something important to tell us now, it is this.
The centrist model — let’s call it Macrons, or in Germany Merzism, or in Britian Starmerism-cum–Burhamism — is crumbling as surely as the lycées of Lyons and Nimes.
System in Decline

Former NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg, left, greeting French President Emmanuel Macron at the NATO Summit in Washington in 2024. (NATO/Flickr, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)
The French social system, one of the nation’s great strengths in the postwar decades, has been in decline for many years. Schools, hospitals, pensions and numerous social services have all suffered in the service of a succession of national budgets reshaped to the benefit of France’s elites.
Macron, a Rothschild merchant banker before his election to the presidency nine years ago, has made increased inequality his signature project. “There is definitely a widespread feeling of neglect,” a Parisian friend said to me the other day. “You see it everywhere.”
There is also the Russophobia and, in keeping with the rest of Core Europe, the condemnable dismantling of the postwar social order in favor of a military-industrial complex on the American model. France’s defense budget is to reach €63.4 billion, $71 billion, by the time Macron leaves office next spring — almost exactly double what it was when he was elected in 2017.
These connections obviously animate the demonstrations now sweeping across France, but they are so far implicit — unspoken of at the barricades. For better or worse, and I would say worse, the French are divided on the Russia question, responsibility for the war in Ukraine and support for the Kiev regime.
Jean–Luc Mélenchon, much favored by France’s youth as leader of the leftist La France Insoumise, France Unbowed, takes that impossibly contradictors position you find among some purported leftists in the United States: Russia is to be condemned for its February 2022 invasion, but NATO and the major Western powers provoked it.
Not workable. Not helpful, either.
A Narrow Theme

Banner at a student protest in Perpignan, France: “Sorry to bother you, we just want a future,” Oct. 2. (Aurelio Cárdenas /Wikimedia Commons/ CC BY 4.0)
In my view this confused understanding of the moment accounts for an apparent reluctance among student demonstrators and their supporters to broaden, let’s say, the theme on the streets.
Some students have declared with pride that they are the heirs of the May ’68 generation — the soixante-huitards, the sixty-eighters. Not quite, I would say: So far, anyway, they appear to lack the larger vision, the consciousness. Have they been propagandized to flinch from a serious critique of power?
As many have remarked, the confrontations between demonstrators and the police have been far more violent than anything one saw in 1968. It is a question of who is responsible for this violence.
The other day The Times of London quoted a 16–year old protester saying, “Without violence no one pays attention to you.” Maybe someone said this and maybe no one did: The Times did not name its source.
But I have heard no one following these events at close range who does not think the French police, never noted for their delicacy, are primarily responsible for those occasions when demonstrations tip into violence.
Stun grenades, rubber bullets, tear gas: These have all been deployed on France’s streets since the first protest broke out on Sept. 18. There are those who suspect — strongly in some cases — that it is the police who are smashing glass doors at some schools and setting fires to others to justify for the public the severity of the official crackdown.
The violence of these events, I am told, is another reason the demands of demonstrators have remained narrow: When protesters are met with violence, the violence of the authorities, self- reflexively becomes the premier issue.
These demonstrations could not have come at a worse time (or maybe a better time) for Macron’s centrist government. It is in political trouble, for one thing, Mélenchon, of La France Insoumise, is not likely to win as a serious contender to replace Macron in next May’s elections, but his sharp rise in the polls — along with Marine Le Pen and her National Rally — suggests a growing determination among voters finally to turn the “centrists” out of power. For another, Macron has made a mess of France’s finances. It is the usual thing: He has cut taxes and raised defense spending but is politically unable to cut social services sufficiently to cover this neoliberal financial regime. Investors are consequently dumping French debt, forcing the yield on French bonds to a 24–year high this week.
Sébastien Lecornu, Macron’s in-over-his-head premier, now speaks of “overlapping crises” but has so far stayed true to Macron’s way with France’s citoyens — expressing sympathy for the students in the streets but committing to nothing by way of substantive reforms in response. From Le Monde’s Thursday editions:
“While the prime minister changed his tone, he did not change his policy. He did not agree to any material or financial demands raised by high school students for renovating school buildings, replacing absent teachers, or improving teacher pay. ‘In the past, there have been too many promises that were not kept, simply because they were not feasible. What I want are concrete, rapid and therefore funded responses,’ he said.
Lecornu’s speech was an admission of powerlessness in the face of the country’s budgetary and political situation, with no majority and pressure from financial markets, leaving little choice just six months before the presidential election. ‘We cannot reopen the same spending with every crisis, especially with higher interest rates,’ he warned. ‘That would mean easing the bill today only to prepare an even heavier one for tomorrow.’”
This is a clear case of ideology leading to paralysis — the malady, I will add, from which Europe’s other centrist regimes suffer — the Merzists, the Burnhamists, et al.
I am always a touch humiliated, I have to say, when I watch the French take to their streets. The street has served as a fourth branch of government ever since Bastille days, as a British scholar recently put it: When the executive, the legislature and the courts all fail, the street is where people can get things done. France’s students may or may not get their buildings fixed up and their teachers paid properly so that they are willing to teach. I hope they do. I hope they begin thinking about power. And I hope the rest of us in the West, remember, or learn for the first time, how useful streets can be.
Patrick Lawrence, a correspondent abroad for many years, chiefly for the International Herald Tribune, is a columnist, essayist, lecturer and author, most recently of Journalists and Their Shadows, available from Clarity Press or via Amazon. Other books include Time No Longer: Americans After the American Century. His Twitter account, @thefloutist, has been restored after years of being censored.
TO MY READERS. Independent publications and those who write for them reach a moment that is difficult and full of promise all at once. On one hand, we assume ever greater responsibilities in the face of mainstream media’s mounting derelictions. On the other, we have found no sustaining revenue model and so must turn directly to our readers for support. I am committed to independent journalism for the duration: I see no other future for American media. But the path grows steeper, and as it does I need your help. This grows urgent now. In recognition of the commitment to independent journalism, please subscribe to The Floutist, or via my Patreon account.
The views expressed are solely those of the author and may or may not reflect those of Consortium News.

When I was young in the 60’s the gvt. was concerned about appearing legitimate, about support of the people. That’s all gone. Big Money rules and they don’t even pretend otherwise.
Fine analysis by Patrick Lawrence and good letters in response . France and Germany are definitely stirring at the level of ordinary people – citoyens . The Zionist- controlled globalists are throwing massive sums of money into keeping the lid on everything . If only the pot might boil over in France …. Tony Kevin
These days, liberal is not liberal, conservative is not conservative, and centrists are nowhere near the center.
In America, the people who claim to be centrist today are the successors of the Reagan Democrats. The right-wing Democrats who supported Reagan. So, the centrists started on the far right of the Democratic Party, then led the party in the big move it has made to the right since Reagan.
Today’s liberals are allies of the bankers, the generals and the industrialists. So, when you hear a pharse like “liberal-authoritarianism”, one has to remember that the liberals now occupy the space that the right-wingers did when they represented the Chamber of Commerce, the bankers, the generals and the industrialists.
In terms of Macron, there has never been anything liberal about him. And he is only a ‘centrist’ because he arranges to be running against LePen in the Grand Finals of every election. A liberal does not rule with the support of only about 20% of the population and behind the swinging clubs and clouds of tear gas that have met every protest in France for a decade. This is, in any sort of real political spectrum, the authoritarianism of the conservatives who always support the bankers and oppose the people. Only the names have been rearranged to avoid clarity. Liberal is no longer liberal, centrist is not in the center, and the conservatives are radicals who want to make changes never seen before.
One of Lawrence’s best.
Thanks for the phrase “liberal-authoritarian”.
Ukraine war provoked, or unprovoked? The question of whether the Ukraine war was provoked or unprovoked has been settled with certainty. NPR informed me of this. When the Ukraine war began, I mistakenly believed that incessant Western meddling in Ukraine affairs over a course of years, fueled by hatred of Russia, provoked Russia, and all peaceful and all diplomatic efforts to keep NATO off its borders having failed,Russia was left with no choice other than the military option.
. However, I was completely wrong. For the five weeks following the war, NPR consistently used the phrase “Russia’s unprovoked invasion of Ukraine” to describe the situation. Living in an isolated area, NPR was my sole source of news. After being repeatedly told by NPR that the invasion was unprovoked, I came to understand that Russia is an evil and vicious country that invades innocent nations driven solely by greed and malice.
My limited capacity for information caused my previous misunderstanding of Russia’s motives to fade away. Now, whenever the word “Russia” is mentioned, the phrase “unprovoked” echoes in my mind like thunderous echoes. What astounds me about Lawrence is his ability to remain calm and objective while describing horrific events of human cruelty, yet he still has a full head of hair. Mine would have been all gone years ago, Torn out in fits of dismay.I also find it distressing that the only solution this astute observer sees for Americans and people worldwide is the streets. It’s a dark but true reality.
NPR is awful. I quit listening and funding when they repeated the ridiculous Hugo Chavez is a Venezuelan dictator bipartisan crap.
Can we admit that the root cause of this cyclical chaos is capitalism? It must expand to continue, but it requires repression and bloodshed to expand. It’s not a sustainable system. We are going to have to come up with a more equitable means of distributing material wealth and power. We can begin by establishing worker owned enterprises that serve human needs without harming life and the natural world. It’s a big task, but we will not survive as a species on the current trajectory.
Ten days once shook the world. That is the title of a good book, by John Reed, iirc, about the Russian Revolution. Good first person history by someone who saw it happen. Some of it got made into the movie “Reds” with Warren Beatty as Reed.
Big tasks can be solved in ten days. Ten days can shake the world.
¡Bravo por los descendientes de los Derechos Humanos!
The West must learn to respect and protect those who work for the common good. Perhaps the youth of France can challenge those of the US to discard the US commercial religion of selfishness+aggression+manipulation = intelligence, lying+cheating+stealing = professionalism, and money = virtue. But the restoration of a humane culture requires elimination of money power from influence upon all three federal branches and the mass media, a distinct challenge.
Big tax increase on the rich.
Seems likely that France is the canary in the coal mine, and that England, Italy, and even Germany can see their future in France. The US led western governments Empire has peaked and is in decline. Inevitably, the decline was going to be messy and chaotic. The only question was how bloody was it going to be. NATO vs Ukraine, and US/Israel vs Iran have provided that answer. The decline is already VERY bloody, and a lot more blood will needlessly be shed.
Looks like its gonna be messier and bloodier still. The authoritarian rulers of Europe appear to believe that only a war with Russia can somehow save them. The classic move of Kings was always to start an external crisis to divert internal revolt. But, those who believe that oppressed people will always rally round the flag during war often fail to account for the anger of people who are dragged into a losing war by a desperate authoritarian leader. Bad can go to worse.
Meanwhile, America appears to be promising a full on attack on Iran to obliterate the nation just after the GOP lies and cons its way through Election Day. If the war does go back to full on status again, that means missiles falling on Israeli cities. The west’s big weakness is the shortage of interceptor missiles, and Israel will shoot them off by the truckload at any incoming salvos. And we know from the last round that even then many will get through. If you are told by your leaders you are to be protected by PAC-man, be very worried and try to get new leaders.
Don’t sell your undertaker and crematorium stocks. Its gonna get bloodier still.