As Trump Preens, Puerto Rico Still Suffers

Many Puerto Ricans continue to live in primitive and dangerous conditions more than a month after Hurricane Maria devastated the U.S. territory in the Caribbean, as Judith Berkan explained to Dennis J Bernstein.


By Dennis J Bernstein

Last Thursday, President Trump gave his administration a “ten out of ten” for its handling of the hurricane recovery in Puerto Rico, However, even as Trump was patting himself and his team on the back the power grid in San Juan went down again throwing the city into darkness.

Flood waters in Puerto Rico, Sept. 22, 2017, after Hurricane Maria slammed the island. (Puerto Rico National Guard photo by Sgt. Jose Ahiram Diaz-Ramos)

More than a month after Hurricane Maria made landfall on Sept. 20, many Puerto Ricans remained in dire straits, especially those needing electricity for respirators or dialysis machines to treat medical conditions. Some back-up generators were burning out due to overuse.

Meanwhile, those living in more remotes areas of Puerto Rico like Vieques and Culebra were still living without any resources, often left to fend for themselves, forced to drink highly polluted water from rivers, or other sources, including those directly connected to superfund sites.

Given Puerto Rico’s ongoing crisis, some officials of the U.S. territory have tried to avoid angering the President. At one point during the meeting in the Oval Office, Trump turned to Puerto Rico’s Governor Ricardo Rossello and asked, “Did we do a great job?” Rossello finessed the President’s question: “You responded immediately, Sir.”

But San Juan Mayor Carmen Yulin Cruz quipped that Trump was right about giving his administration a “10” if it was out of 100. “If it is a 10 out of a scale of 100, of course, it is still a failing grade,” she said on CNN’s “New Day” on Friday.

In an interview late Thursday, I spoke with Flashpoints contributor Judith Berkan in San Juan, whose electricity had again failed, along with millions of other Puerto Ricans. Berkan is a human rights activist and attorney who deals with land rights, and has been a resident on the U.S.’ island colony for the last 40 years.

Dennis Bernstein: What’s the latest regarding the situation on the ground? Is the situation beginning to improve?

Judith Berkan: In some ways, the situation keeps getting worse. For example, just a half an hour ago most, if not all, of the San Juan area lost electricity. The power comes and goes. You get it for a couple days and you get a sense of some routine in your life and then it disappears again. So the San Juan metropolitan area, which in some ways is the economic motor of the country, is still in the dark. I live in an apartment building which has generators. There has been a fire sale of generators here at very exorbitant prices. People are being gouged.

Dennis Bernstein: Talk about the situation in terms of power at medical facilities.

Judith Berkan: I just spoke with a friend of mine who spent all day waiting for ambulatory surgery and then the lights went out. About three-quarters of the hospitals on the island are working but most of those are working on generators. Generators cause all sorts of other problems. The air contamination is frightening and we are seeing more respiratory diseases.

Because of the uncertainty of power, hospitals are limiting their operations and sending people who can afford it off the island to have operations. Because doctor’s offices are closed by and large, emergency rooms have become, in effect, doctor’s offices.

There has been a propagation of contagious diseases. Pneumonia is showing up quite a bit. We have had torrential rains this past week. In October, so far, we have had over six inches of rain, which has resulted in huge floods. The water is still contaminated by animal carcasses and rodent urine and that kind of thing. We are seeing scabies, which is one of those diseases that can pass from an animal to a human being.

We also have a devastating situation with the tarps. Something like 250,000 homes have totally lost their roofs and many more have lost part of their roofs. The FEMA director here was saying that the only tarps that have been distributed were some 45,000 that were on stock here in Puerto Rico. When the request was made for more tarps to the States, they said that none were available. So now they are being manufactured and they estimate that next week 500,000 will arrive.

As far as the job that the US is doing, they are not offering enough aid, they are offering us loans at a time when Puerto Rico’s indebtedness is extraordinary to begin with. There are still communities, 29 days after the storm, who have not been reached by a single governmental agent. Only about 10 percent of roads are passable and there is still debris all over the streets.

Dennis Bernstein: Drinkable water is in short supply. This is like going back a hundred years.

Judith Berkan: People are drinking from creeks. There was a scandal last week when it was discovered that people were drinking water coming from a superfund site. Personally, as someone who has had water most of this time, I will not drink the water that comes out of the tap. I have no idea whether the water is contaminated or not.

I knew that Trump and Rossello would be meeting today but I hadn’t heard Trump’s statement. To say that the federal effort has been a ten out of ten would be laughable if it were not so sad. I mean, drop Mr. Trump off in the middle of the island and see if he can get water or a roof over his head.

Dennis Bernstein: The president made a big deal about the minimum number of deaths so far.

Judith Berkan: Every estimate is different. The most recent estimate is 49. 103 [people] are still missing. There are still cadavers being found in river beds. Beyond that, there are many consequential deaths that are not being taken account of. This includes people with respiratory illnesses, people who need frozen insulin, people on rationed dialysis.

No one has studied the psychological effects of all this, but there have been several suicides. So the number of deaths is going to go way up. And even if there have been only 49 deaths, that is not the true measure of the suffering or the responsibility of the United States with respect to this colony.

Dennis Bernstein: And I imagine the situation is a great deal worse in places like Vieques.

A map with the continental USA and Puerto Rico highlighted red. (Wikipedia)

Judith Berkan: Vieques and Culebra are two offshore islands with very little access to goods and supplies. There are about eight or nine thousand people on Vieques and about 1,500 on Culebra. Those people are completely on their own. There have been reports of widespread food insecurity. There is only one hospital on Vieques and I don’t believe there are any on Culebra. The shipping out there is very unreliable. They are really suffering, as are people in the mountains and also in the poorer communities within the cities.

I do want to say that there has been a lot of solidarity, a lot of aid coming in. We suggest that donations be made to the community organizations, not to corporate organizations like the Red Cross or the First Lady’s Fund.

Dennis Bernstein: Vieques had the hell bombed out of it for decades and the remnants of that are going to cause people to get sick for years to come.

Judith Berkan: Before the storm hit, there were cancer pockets in Vieques. For a period of about thirty years Culebra was bombed by the US Navy and in Vieques the bombing went on for about sixty years, from the 1940’s until 2003. They left Culebra in the 1970’s and Vieques in 2003, in both cases after massive protests.

When the Navy left, they just left the contaminants there. There is unexploded ordinance but more dangerous are the contaminants that have made their way into the ground water. I have no confidence in the water supply, either on Vieques and Culebra or here on the main island. A lot of people are receiving bottled water but I don’t know how long it is going to be sustained.

Dennis Bernstein: Who is in charge?

Judith Berkan: That is the question of the hour. Nobody knows. There is a lot of finger pointing. The local government is pointing at the feds. FEMA is here, the Army Corps of Engineers is here, the local government, the municipal government. We also have private security firms here, such as the current incarnation of Blackwater. You see the US military here. And everyone points fingers at everyone else. No one knows where to go to get certain things.

Dennis Bernstein: Any positive developments?

Judith Berkan: One positive development has been that grassroots organizations, progressive organizations, agricultural collectives, and labor organizations have come together to reach out to the people. But as for officialdom, it is totally unknown who is in charge.

Dennis J Bernstein is a host of “Flashpoints” on the Pacifica radio network and the author of Special Ed: Voices from a Hidden Classroom. You can access the audio archives at

17 comments for “As Trump Preens, Puerto Rico Still Suffers

  1. irina
    October 24, 2017 at 15:44

    Given the prior events in Texas and Florida, the shortage of tarps is totally understandable.

  2. Brad Owen
    October 24, 2017 at 07:00

    Hurricanes, tornadoes, earthquakes, floods, further wrecking a decrepit infrastructure that has been neglected for 50 goddamn years by both democrats and republicans. President Carter said it was outdated back in the 70s. The Interstate highways were the last Great Infrastructure Project launched in Eisenhower’s time.There are dams and water management systems on the drawing boards, put there over 50-60-70 years ago for chrissakes, gathering dust, that would have mitigated all the death & destruction wrought by nature. But the Synarchists gained the ascendancy when they had JFK murdered, and it was only a matter of time when War and Austerity would become the new Normal, and the General Welfare of the People would go begging and starving. Their time is over, though, and a new Era is QUICKLY approaching. We are going to walk upon a New Silk Road, providing the means for fixing all of these problems. THAT is the next Movement.

  3. October 23, 2017 at 19:05

    Are Puerto Ricans doing enough work to help themselves? I read that in the days after the storm many truck drivers did not show up for work.

    • October 23, 2017 at 21:19

      That would largely depend on the source of what you read and why the truck drivers didn’t show up for work. 1-they could have been impacted by the hurrycane themselves 2-there was a one week delay in relief aid 3- How many businesses were open after the hurrycane?…I seriously doubt they didn’t show up for work because they didn’t feel like it. I suggest you check with your source and consider the possible motives for such a ridiculous claim.

      • October 24, 2017 at 07:07

        “… That would largely depend on the source of what you read …”

        well, look at this article. No focus at all on what the PR government, people, institutions are doing for themselves. Did anyone organize work gangs of men to work to clear the roads? Have there been any reports of why the truck drivers did not show up to work? What about the PRs living in the US? Have many returned to the island to join rebuilding and aid efforts? The media does not seem interested in reporting on PR other than to be critical of Trump.

        • Zachary Smith
          October 24, 2017 at 11:46

          The media does not seem interested in reporting on PR other than to be critical of Trump.

          Have you examined pictures from Puerto Rico? Have you looked at any articles/essays about the place from any sources besides Hannity/Limpaugh?

          The roads weren’t just littered, but in places were actually destroyed. Ditto for the bridges. Trucks require fuel and don’t get especially good gas mileage, and you don’t get fuel from fuel stations when there is no electricity to operate the pumps, and there wasn’t in the early days. They started with 100% power outages. Because the Trumpies were slow on the uptake, there weren’t even any loads to haul for quite a while.

        • October 24, 2017 at 18:57

          Zachary below is correct, extreme fuel shortage, no electricity. And yes communal food sharing and road clearance. In fact in one place state security stopped people from building a bridge across a river.

          P.R. is not allowed, as are all the States are, to lessen it’s debt by declaring bankruptcy.

    • Joe Wallace
      October 25, 2017 at 03:59

      Steve Richter:

      Why would truck drivers show up for work if the roads were impassable?

  4. mike k
    October 23, 2017 at 17:39

    With friends like the United States, who needs enemies? Puerto Rico is a US colony – there simply to be exploited, and abandoned. Besides factor in that Trump is a white racist. What does he care about anybody south of the 48 States?

    • Al Pinto
      October 23, 2017 at 18:32

      In all fairness, you could have called most previous presidents “white racist”, based on their past history with Puerto Rico. Singling out just the current one shows more than you’ve intended to…

    • dfc
      October 23, 2017 at 19:46

      Or the North either. Don’t forget about the Eskimos too!

    • Annie
      October 23, 2017 at 20:56

      I agree with Al, when have we ever been a friend to Puerto Rico under any presidency? That he is a racist is so bandied about it has become meaningless. Aside from some of his rhetoric which some have interpreted as racist what has he done that shows he’s a racist? The talk of deportation? Well Obama was known as the deporter and chief, over 2 million and many were only guilty of petty crimes. So far, he hasn’t been responsible for killing some one million Muslims, and destroying their countries. Actions speak louder then words, as they say.

  5. Annie
    October 23, 2017 at 16:45

    I wish some journalist would right an article on why Puerto Rico is in the state it’s in, due to hurricane Maria, and not use Trump as his, intro, implying he’s totally to blame. Certainly one of the problems is that Puerto Rico has an outstanding debt due to decades of mismanagement. It also has a highly flawed power grid with power going on and off, and from what I’ve read the power authority declared bankruptcy in July. Power outages were routine, even in cities. Not to mention it’s horrible infrastructure. It took Obama 7 years into his presidency to offer some relief from their debt, by putting a moratorium on it, which has expired. It reminds me of Hillary Clinton blaming Russia,and just about everyone else for her loss, and the democratic party backs her up. Never do they mention past history, like the democratic party lost interest in blue collar guys and gals somewhere back in the seventies and for the most part represent the top 10 percent in this country, although they’ll claim it is otherwise, and no doubt it is the main reason she lost. This doesn’t mean that I don’t think we should do more, because that would not be true.

    • john wilson
      October 24, 2017 at 05:12

      Annie, the reason Puerto Rico is in debt is because it borrowed money to try to survive on a day to day basis in the first place. They had no hope of paying this money back and were simply putting off the time when the country would be destitute. They never had any money to fix the grid, water supply etc, because the place is impoverished. Puerto Rico has no real export market so what little they earn is spent on just getting by and there’s nothing for investment. 10% of the American military budget would probably sort them out but that would shave off a bit of the war companies profit and that would never do.

  6. dfc
    October 23, 2017 at 16:07

    This is so outrageous! I bet Trump is sitting on all those funds in a big vault in the White House. There are so many people in the White House and FEMA who get their jollys out of seeing other people suffer and therefore like to prolong natural disasters. If Trump wanted he could snap his fingers and write a check for a trillion dollars to completely rebuild the island of Puerto Rico with new roads, schools, hospitals and homes as well as cancel Puerto Rico’s debt. But it is the same pattern as Bush with Katrina. If Obama, Pelosi & Shumer were in office Puerto Rico would be completely up and running withing two weeks! I hope people realize this and start voting for the “can do” team again to get America up and running again.

    • Annie
      October 23, 2017 at 16:47

      You have just proven what I wrote.

      • Al Pinto
        October 23, 2017 at 18:33

        Right on cue… :)

Comments are closed.